Winter wind and solar lulls reveal Europe's need for costly backup power

This article has been reviewed according to Science X's editorial process and policies. Editors have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility:

This summer, record-breaking heat waves in Europe led to extreme stress on the power system, with high evening electricity prices due to air-conditioning demand, insufficient battery storage and outages at thermal and nuclear power plants. Events such as these highlight the challenge of maintaining a reliable power supply during extreme weather.

The same applies to so-called compound events, when a combination of meteorological factors leads to extreme situations. In late 2024, periods of low wind and solar generation across Europe triggered sharp spikes in electricity prices and increased reliance on fossil fuels and imports.

In a new study published in Nature Sustainability, researchers from the Technical University of Denmark, DTU, and Newcastle University modeled a future net-zero European power system and tested it against 80 years of historical weather data to understand how it would handle periods of low wind and solar generation combined with high demand.

They developed new ways to assess how well future power systems can withstand these conditions, underscoring the growing need for reliable backup capacity as Europe expands renewable energy. Based on historical data, they conclude that the risk is greatest during winter, when cold, still conditions persist over several days—too long for batteries to compensate.

"Future energy systems will rely heavily on renewables, as they are the cheapest form of generating electricity and increase our energy independence. However, to cover the power deficit when demand outstrips production, we need backup capacities," says Marta Victoria, professor at DTU Wind.

"We also find that the capacities needed to keep the system secure during these periods are otherwise used rarely. They are more expensive than renewables or other technologies like hydropower, making them difficult to finance under current market conditions and leading to high electricity prices."

The study examines so-called system-defining events, periods when the power system faces particularly high strain and investment decisions are most affected. Using long-term weather data and detailed modeling of the European grid, the researchers identify when and how these situations arise and what they mean for planning future energy infrastructure.

To carry out the analysis, the researchers used an open-source energy system model and constructed a counterfactual model of what a net-zero power system using 80 years of historical weather data (spanning 1941–2021) would look like. This makes it possible to capture both typical conditions and more extreme years that could shape future systems.

System-defining events are identified using a metric based on "shadow prices," a modeling concept that reflects the stress level of the system in meeting demand at a given moment. In practical terms, higher values indicate the need for greater capacity in generation, storage and transmission, shaping investments as well as the design of the energy system.

These events are often referred to as energy droughts, periods when wind and solar generation simultaneously fall short. Because Europe's electricity grid is highly interconnected, periods like these can affect large parts of the continent at once.

For example, in 2021, unusually low wind speeds across northwestern and central Europe reduced wind power output for months, contributing to higher electricity prices. A few years earlier, a cold spell in January 2017 combined low wind generation with high heating demand, increasing pressure on electricity systems in several countries.

"Our approach identifies when the system is under the most pressure, what drives those situations, and how the system reacts. The greatest risk occurs in the dark winter months when low wind speeds and cold temperatures coincide. So, extreme weather, as far as the energy system is concerned, doesn't necessarily mean 'bad weather,'" says Aleksander Grochowicz, postdoctoral researcher at DTU Wind and lead author of the study.

"We often use the German term dunkelflaute to describe these lulls. Under those conditions, we mostly lack power capacities, and we have energy available, but we cannot dispatch it."

The study also distinguishes between short-term and long-term resilience challenges. Short-term resilience refers to the system's ability to cope with events lasting hours or days, such as sudden drops in renewable generation. Long-term resilience concerns the overall design of the system, including how much generation and storage capacity should be built to withstand variability over years or decades.

"We show that backup power capacities improve short-term resilience, whereas long-term resilience comes from the adequate size of the system and sufficient renewables," says Grochowicz.

A key finding is tha